In the heat of battle on DUI cases, we often interview and cross examine police officers. After one such interview in a DUI case, in Northern Arizona, an officer told me, “Nabbing your client was like shooting fish in a barrel.” I asked what he meant by that. He said, “Your client had no idea what he was doing. I had the upper hand the entire time.”
That hit close to home for me. After hearing the same story over and over again, from officers who employ aggressive investigation tactics to clients who don’t know their rights, it’s clear that most people don’t know what to do when they get pulled over for a DUI investigation. Here are some of the most common complaints – and our thoughts.
1. The officer ordered me out of my car… he can’t do that!
Wrong. He or she can do that. The police officer can order a driver to get out of their vehicle for any traffic stop, even a civil traffic violation like Arizona Revised Statutes section 28-701(A), or a stop sign violation, or even a “failure to produce evidence of financial responsibility” situation. The officer can have a driver get out and walk back to the patrol vehicle. This can be for further investigation of the traffic violation or for police officer safety.
2. The officer started questioning me about contraband and drugs… he can’t do that!
Partially right and partially wrong. Arizona law provides that a police officer may stop and detain a person “as is reasonably necessary to investigate an actual or suspected violation of any traffic law committed in the officer’s presence. . .” A.R.S. section 13-3883(B). The stop and detention must not extend beyond what is reasonably necessary to investigate an actual or suspected violation of Arizona traffic law. A police officer can extend a traffic stop to a more significant criminal investigation if the officer has reasonable suspicion that criminal activity is afoot. Or, the officer can complete the traffic stop and ask the driver if the driver would answer some more questions. Most drivers don’t know that they can say no. So, the conversation becomes a “mere encounter” or “consensual encounter” and the officer is free to keep asking questions.
3. The officer never told me that I could leave… he has to tell me when I’m free to go!
Wrong. The ability to leave is based on a totality of the circumstances analysis. For the officer to detain a person for further investigation beyond the traffic stop, the totality of the circumstances must give rise to a particularized and founded suspicion that a motorist is engaged in criminal activity. State v. Acosta, 166 Ariz. 254, 801 P.2d 49 (App. 1990). If you want to leave, and want to stop answering questions, then say to the officer (politely), “I do not want to answer any more questions. Am I free to leave?” If you are free to leave, then go. If you are not free to leave, then ask, “Why am I being detained?” But at that point, if you are detained, do not answer any more incriminating questions.
4. When an officer asks me if I drank alcohol, I have to answer.
Wrong. Nobody has to make any self-incriminating statements. That’s why you have the right to remain silent.
5. When the officer made me do Field Sobriety Tests (FST’s), I had no choice.
Wrong, wrong, wrong. In Arizona, an officer cannot force you to do FST’s. In fact, all FST’s are voluntary. Officers don’t tell you that when you’re on the side of the road. They usually say, “I need you to do some tests for me.” But you can politely decline. This includes the horizontal gaze nystagmus (HGN), or what is also referred to as the “eye test” or “pen test.” FST’s can also present a risk of harm to you, which is another reason you can decline (e.g., if you have a prior head injury or leg injury).
6. The officer made me do a breath test at the scene, called a Portable Breath Test (PBT)… he can’t do that!
Right. The officer cannot force you to submit to a PBT. But, the Intoxilyzer 8000 is another story.
7. The officer took me to the station and told me that my driving privileges will be suspended for 12 months if I refuse to blow into the Intoxilyzer 8000… he can’t do that!
Wrong. If the officer has probable cause that you are driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs, the officer does have the power to ask you to provide a breath, blood, or urine sample for scientific testing. This situation is covered by Arizona’s admin per se / implied consent laws. And yes, if you refuse, you’ll get a 12 month suspension of your driving privileges in Arizona. Remember, the privilege to drive is exactly that—a privilege—not a constitutional or fundamental right.
These are only some of the issues we routinely find in DUI cases in Flagstaff and across Northern Arizona. If you get pulled over for a DUI, you should be polite and respectful. But you don’t have to give the officer incriminating evidence for no reason. You can decline FST’s, decline to answer interrogation questions, and decline a PBT. If you get arrested, then that means the officer still believes that he or she has sufficient probable cause that you are driving under the influence.
For a free DUI or criminal defense consultation for any case in Northern Arizona, call us today or use our free Contact Form at the top of the page.